← Back to Check a domain

More than one DMARC record

A second service asked you to add a DMARC record, and now there are two. Receivers throw both away, even when each is correct on its own.

RFC 9989 section 4.10: "If multiple DMARC Policy Records are returned for a single target, they are all discarded." On your main domain that leaves no DMARC policy and no reports. On a subdomain, receivers go on to the parent's record and apply its policy, so check the parent's result too.

It usually happens when a second service asks you to "add a DMARC record" and the new one goes in beside the old one. Other TXT records at the same name don't count, as long as they don't start v=DMARC1.

dig +short TXT _dmarc.example.com

Put your domain in place of example.com, then count the lines that contain v=DMARC1, including V=DMARC1 or v = DMARC1. More than one is this finding. On Windows, use nslookup -type=TXT _dmarc.example.com. Details → on your result shows the same records.

Merge them

  1. Pick one record to keep. Ending the conflict puts its policy into force at once: p=quarantine sends mail from any service you haven't set up to spam, and p=reject refuses it. Unless your reports already show every service you send through passing DMARC, set the kept record to p=none before you delete the other. The same goes for sp= and np= in the kept record, which cover subdomains: set them to none unless you've checked your subdomains' mail.
  2. Copy every report address from the other record into its rua= tag, separated by commas, so no recipient is lost.
  3. Delete the other record at your DNS provider.
  4. Run the check again. One record should remain.
  5. Once the reports show your services pass, tighten the policy to p=quarantine, then p=reject.

The result shows:

More than one DMARC record
Receivers ignore DMARC when there is more than one record.

Last updated .